Skip to main content

Research

Self-interacting dark matter

If dark-matter particles scatter off each other, halos conduct heat. Their centers first develop low-density cores and can later collapse to densities far above those of cold dark matter. I develop the simulation codes that follow this evolution, from cosmological volumes down to the final stages of collapse in individual halos.

Why consider self-interactions?

Cold, collisionless dark matter (CDM) describes the large-scale structure of the Universe very well. On the scales of dwarf galaxies, comparisons between gravity-only CDM simulations and observations have raised several possible tensions: the cusp–core problem, the abundance of satellites, the "too big to fail" problem and the diversity of dwarf-galaxy rotation curves. How significant these tensions are is still debated, because baryonic physics, selection effects and the difficulty of inferring halo properties can relieve at least some of them.

Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) is one of the most widely studied alternatives (Spergel & Steinhardt 2000). Dark-matter particles can scatter off each other, and the strength of the interaction is set by the cross section per unit mass, σ/m. At the typical velocities of dwarf galaxies, values of roughly 0.1–10 cm2 g−1 produce cores like those observed. Galaxy clusters, where particles move much faster, constrain a constant cross section to considerably smaller values.

This is why the velocity dependence matters. A cross section that is large at the low relative velocities in dwarfs and small at cluster velocities can satisfy both. Such a dependence arises naturally if the interaction is mediated by a light force carrier with a Yukawa-like potential, as in many hidden-sector extensions of the Standard Model. Halo structure then becomes a probe of the microphysics of the dark sector.

What self-interactions do to a halo

Repeated scattering moves energy through a halo and acts as heat conduction. A CDM halo starts with a cusp whose velocity dispersion rises outward, so heat initially flows inward. The center heats up, expands and forms an approximately isothermal, lower-density core.

Core formation is not the end of the story. Once the core is hotter than its surroundings, the heat flux reverses. A self-gravitating system has a negative heat capacity: when the core loses energy, it contracts and heats up further, which drives a runaway known as gravothermal core collapse, first studied in globular clusters. For cross sections of order 10–100 cm2 g−1, the collapse can raise the central densities of dwarf halos a few orders of magnitude above CDM within the age of the Universe.

Central density of an isolated SIDM halo versus time over about 30 billion years: it falls to a minimum after about 5 Gyr, rises slowly for 25 Gyr, and then climbs steeply to about 10,000 times the NFW scale density at 30.5 Gyr. Two simulations with different random seeds lie on top of each other.
Both phases in one simulation. The central density ρc, in units of the NFW scale density ρs, of a 1010 M☉ halo with σ/m = 30 cm2 g−1, simulated with NORI and 108 particles inside the virial radius. The density first falls as the core forms, then rises slowly and finally runs away; the inset enlarges the final collapse. Solid and dashed curves use independent random numbers for the scatterings; the dotted curve is a run with ten times fewer particles. Figure: Zier et al. 2026, NORI.

The collapse phase is what makes SIDM interesting beyond the original small-scale problems. Strong gravitational lenses and perturbed cold stellar streams in the Milky Way point to dark substructures that appear denser than CDM predicts at the same mass. Core-collapsed SIDM subhalos are a natural candidate for such perturbers. Collapse in massive halos at high redshift has also been proposed as a route to seeding supermassive black holes. Testing these ideas requires reliable predictions for the late stages of collapse, when the central density rises by several orders of magnitude.

Two side-by-side dark-matter density maps of the same Milky-Way-mass halo at redshift zero, with a 100 kpc scale bar. Left, cold dark matter: a sharp central peak and many compact bright subhalos. Right, SIDM with a cross section of 10 square centimeters per gram: a broader center and fewer compact subhalos.
Dark-matter density at z = 0 in a Milky-Way-mass halo simulated with AREPO-2 in CDM (left) and with my SIDM solver at σ/m = 10 cm2 g−1 (right), from the same initial conditions. With self-interactions the host halo develops a core, and the abundance of subhalos is reduced, most strongly at low masses. Simulations: Zier et al. 2026, SIDM in AREPO-2.

How SIDM is simulated

In principle one would solve the Boltzmann equation with a collision term, but this is far too expensive over the dynamic range of structure formation. The most widely used approach instead adds Monte Carlo scattering to an N-body code. Each simulation particle stands for a patch of phase space, not for a single dark-matter particle. In every time step, each particle i looks at its nearest neighbors j and scatters with each of them with a probability

P(i|j) = ½ mj W(rij, hi) (σ/m) |vi − vj| Δt,

where W is a smoothing kernel of radius hi that weights the pair by its separation rij and Δt is the time step. An accepted pair receives new velocities in its center-of-momentum frame that conserve momentum and, for elastic scattering, kinetic energy. The idea is simple; making it accurate deep in the collapse is not:

  • Conservation across processors. In a parallel code, the two partners of a scattering may live on different processors, and one particle can scatter several times in one step. If two events are computed from the same outdated velocity, energy is no longer conserved; if conflicting events are cancelled instead, the scattering rate is underestimated. Both errors grow during collapse, when scattering becomes frequent.
  • Time steps. Every pair probability must stay small, so the time step has to shrink with the local collision time. In a dense, collapsing core this limit is far stricter than the gravitational one. Individual time steps save work but can introduce systematic energy errors, and small energy errors change the heat balance and hence the collapse time.
  • Resolution. As the core contracts it loses mass, so fewer and fewer particles sample it, and a fixed gravitational softening resolves it less and less well. A scattering kernel larger than the mean free path can also cause spurious heat transport.

My codes

I address these problems with two complementary codes. The SIDM module in AREPO-2 is built for cosmological simulations, with or without baryons, where halos and subhalos form in their full environment. NORI is a GPU-native code for isolated halos that trades generality for speed and reproducibility, so that the late collapse can be followed with many more particles.

Papers

  1. A novel implementation of self-interacting dark matter in AREPO

    Zier, Shen, Tran et al. · MNRAS 552, stag1674 · 2026

    The SIDM solver in AREPO-2: a dedicated dark-matter neighbor tree, consistent multiple scattering across MPI tasks, and a per-pair time-step criterion.

    arXiv ADS DOI

  2. NORI: a GPU-accelerated code for simulating self-gravitating and self-interacting dark matter

    Zier, Pakmor, Shen et al. · submitted · 2026

    NORI, a CPU and GPU N-body code for isolated SIDM halos, used to follow a halo with 10⁸ particles inside the virial radius to 10⁴ times the NFW scale density.

    arXiv ADS

  3. Self-Interacting Dark Matter: From Particle Physics Theories to Structure Formation Simulations

    Rosenlyst, Tran, Zier et al. · submitted · 2026

    From particle-physics models to simulation inputs, with anisotropic, multi-state, inelastic and dissipative scattering and dark-matter decay implemented in AREPO-2.

    arXiv ADS

  4. Role of prompt cusps in driving the core collapse of self-interacting dark matter halos

    Tran, Gilman, Delos et al. · PRD 113, 083030 · 2026

    Steep prompt cusps at the centers of halos slow the early core-formation phase by a factor of about two.

    arXiv ADS DOI

  5. Novel density profile for isothermal cores of dark matter halos

    Tran, Shen, Vogelsberger et al. · PRD 113, 063024 · 2026

    An analytic density profile for isothermal SIDM cores that describes halos from early thermalization to late core collapse.

    arXiv ADS DOI